Unsolved Couple

Unsolved Couple
  • 4.9 (55)
  • TRUE CRIME
  • UPDATED WEEKLY

Unsolved Couple is your weekly throwback to the haunting world of Unsolved Mysteries. Hosts Ben and Sierra revisit the classic cases that gave us chills in the ’90s—disappearances, strange encounters, and stories that still don’t add up. We break down each case with updates, theories, and insights you might have missed, blending nostalgia with today’s true-crime curiosity. Whether you grew up watching Robert Stack or you’re just finding these cases for the first time, join us for mystery, intrigue, and a touch of humor as we unravel the unknown—together. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

  1. 6D AGO

    A Marriage Adrift, a Socialite Silenced, and a Vanishing Daughter

    A woman dies slowly in the freezing waters of Lake Superior—not by drowning, but by something quieter… colder. Her husband says it was an accident. The state says he watched her die. In Phoenix, a wealthy widow is executed in her sleep. No struggle. No clear suspect. Just a voice on an answering machine—and a man who may not exist. And decades earlier, a young woman walks away from her family after one final argument… promising never to return. She keeps that promise. Three cases. Each one circling the same unsettling idea: Sometimes people don’t vanish. Sometimes they’re erased… or they choose to disappear. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support. 👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple 📧 Email: unsolvedcouplepod@gmail.com 📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast 📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod Original artwork by @evelinejones3 * We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

    1h 29m

  2. MAR 17

    Driven to Chicago, Fooled by a Phantom, and Torn Apart by a Father

    In this episode of Unsolved Couple, the truth slips through fingers, changes names, and refuses to stay buried. Nineteen-year-old Chad Mower leaves home for a normal workday… and somehow ends up dead in a locked garage on Chicago’s South Side. Authorities call it suicide. His family sees something else: injuries, missing evidence, and a trail that leads into something far darker. Then there’s Todd Mueller, a master manipulator who doesn’t just commit fraud, he performs it. With forged court documents, stolen identities, and a sense of humor that borders on cruel, Mueller drains estates, frees prisoners, taunts police, and even escapes custody, turning a nationwide manhunt into his own private game. In Texas, a woman named Lorene Roberts disappears for decades after a life marked by hardship, mental illness, and impossible choices. Unknown to her, she is the heir to a fortune… until one broadcast changes everything. And finally, the devastating story of the Vess family. In 1974, Wanda Vess is murdered by her husband, leaving nine children to be scattered across foster homes and adoptions. Years later, one daughter begins the impossible task of putting her family back together piece by piece… hoping one day, all nine will stand in the same room again. From unanswered deaths to criminals who laugh at the system, from lives lost in silence to families rebuilt against the odds, this episode asks: What’s more dangerous… what we don’t know, or what refuses to be found? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support. 👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple 📧 Email: unsolvedcouplepod@gmail.com 📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast 📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod Original artwork by @evelinejones3 * We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

    1h 23m

  3. MAR 10

    A Killer’s Road Trip, a Widow Robbed Blind, & Searching for a Mother

    In this episode of Unsolved Couple, violence, betrayal, and long-lost family ties collide. First, convicted killer Michael St. Clair escapes from an Oklahoma jail with fellow inmate Dennis Reese, unleashing a brutal crime spree that stretches across eight states. Their rampage leaves multiple victims dead and law enforcement racing to stop two men who vowed they would never be taken alive. Then we travel to a lonely mountaintop estate in Tennessee, where society widow Ellen McClung Berry fell under the spell of a charming stranger named Dan Tondevold. Within a few years, Tondevold drained her fortune, vanished with millions, and left behind a body in a swamp that may or may not have been his. Next, a public defender’s investigator searches for the one person he cannot find: his own mother. After losing custody in a bitter 1949 divorce, Annie Currie disappeared from the lives of her sons. Decades later, Jim Currie continues the search for the woman he barely remembers. Finally, a Depression-era act of kindness echoes across half a century. When a struggling father left his daughters temporarily with a Tennessee farming family, no one imagined the girls would vanish from their lives forever… until a television broadcast reunited them more than fifty years later. From fugitives on the run to fortunes stolen in plain sight, from lost parents to long-delayed reunions, this episode asks: How far can someone run before the past catches up? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support. 👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple 📧 Email: unsolvedcouplepod@gmail.com 📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast 📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod Original artwork by @evelinejones3 * We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

    1h 35m

  4. MAR 2

    Adopted Twice, Buried in the Desert, and Lost to Flame

    In this unforgettable episode, coincidence feels almost supernatural. Two women named Barbara grow up just miles apart in Los Angeles. Both adopted. Both named Barbara Ann. Both raised by mothers named Rose. Both unaware they share the same birth mother. Then one afternoon, a box of forgotten adoption papers reveals a name: Victoria Baumgartner. And suddenly, best friends become sisters. Their miracle reunion is shadowed by secrecy. Records destroyed. A doctor who took answers to his grave. A mother who vanished from history. Then, in San Diego, Marine Captain Jeffrey Digman is found dead with a gunshot wound to the head. Authorities rule it suicide. His parents call it murder. Missing evidence. A cut up diary. A safe that disappears. A trajectory that makes no sense. In Florida, more than two dozen churches burn in a wave of arson that leaves congregations guarding their sanctuaries at night. In Oklahoma, domestic violence survivor Theresa Stamper watches her husband, Paul Stamper, escape custody… only to be captured within hours of the broadcast after viewers flood the FBI with calls. And in the vast desert near Farmington, New Mexico, the legend of Leon Trabuco lingers. Sixteen tons of gold. Secret flights. A burial site never mapped. A fortune that may still lie beneath the sand. From sisterhood to suspicion, from flames to fugitives, from grief to greed, this episode asks: What survives longer… truth, or the secrets meant to bury it? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support. 👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple 📧 Email: unsolvedcouplepod@gmail.com 📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast 📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod Original artwork by @evelinejones3 * We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

    1h 40m

  5. FEB 24

    UFOs Over Eupen, Small-Town Secrets & the Perfect Disappearance

    In this episode of Unsolved Couple, we unravel one of the strangest waves of UFO sightings in modern history, a small-town police chief’s suspicious death, and a white-collar fugitive who vanished into thin air. In 1989 and 1990, thousands of witnesses across Belgium reported massive black triangular UFOs hovering silently over highways. The Belgian Air Force scrambled F-16s. Radar locked on. The objects accelerated beyond conventional aircraft limits. No sonic boom. No explanation. Was the so-called Belgian UFO Wave mass hysteria, classified military tech, or something far stranger? Then we travel to Rock Creek, Ohio, where Police Chief Robert Hamrick declared war on a violent gang terrorizing his town. Months later, he was found in a crashed patrol car. Blood in the backseat. Missing weapon. Ignition switched off. His death ruled an accident. His family believes it was murder. Finally, we examine the disappearance of Detroit executive Philip Breen, accused of orchestrating a $10 million mortgage fraud scheme before walking away from his wife and life without a trace. Did he stage his escape? Is he still alive? And how do you grieve someone who chose to disappear? UFO sightings. Police corruption. Embezzlement. Radar evidence. Small-town conspiracy. Financial crime. Unexplained disappearances. Three cases. Three vanishings. One episode. Subscribe to Unsolved Couple for weekly deep dives into unsolved mysteries, cold cases, and unexplained phenomena. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support. 👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple 📧 Email: unsolvedcouplepod@gmail.com 📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast 📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod Original artwork by @evelinejones3 * We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

    1h 17m

  6. FEB 17

    Blown Apart, Locked Away, and Left for Dead

    In this episode of Unsolved Couple, we explore four devastating stories where trust became a weapon and institutions failed the people they were meant to protect. First, a series of pipe bomb attacks targets religious broadcasters, including Pat Robertson and **John OsteenThen, we follow the nightmare of Patty Stallings, a young mother accused of poisoning her infant son, convicted on faulty medical evidence, and imprisoned while pregnant, until science and public pressure finally exposed the truth. Next, we revisit the harrowing story of Cathy Williams, a teenage abuse survivor betrayed by the system and nearly erased by her stepfather’s badge, until one anonymous deputy chose to listen. Finally, we examine the murder of Sally Garrity, a woman who believed she had found love, only to be trapped in a relationship with a violent fugitive who vanished after killing her. From religious extremism to wrongful convictions, from institutional corruption to intimate violence, this episode asks one haunting question: How many lives were destroyed before anyone decided to look closer? Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support. 👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple 📧 Email: unsolvedcouplepod@gmail.com 📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast 📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod Original artwork by @evelinejones3 * We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

    1h 33m
  7. Bonus: Unsolved Couple Chat: The Nancy Guthrie Case...

    FEB 11

    Bonus: Unsolved Couple Chat: The Nancy Guthrie Case...

    In this bonus episode, Sierra and Ben step away from Unsolved Mysteries to talk about a real-life mystery unfolding in their own backyard. They sit down for an open, honest conversation about the Nancy Guthrie case, sharing what they know, what stands out, and what still doesn’t make sense. From living in Tucson and understanding Pima County’s history with cases like this, to discussing patterns, timelines, and unanswered questions, this episode is about thoughtful exploration.A candid conversation about the mystery, and the questions surrounding Nancy Guthrie. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support. 👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple 📧 Email: unsolvedcouplepod@gmail.com 📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast 📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod Original artwork by @evelinejones3 * We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

    37 min

  8. FEB 10

    Past Lives, Death Calls, & a Glamorous Con Artist

    In this episode of Unsolved Couple, we unravel one of the most chilling collections of mysteries ever featured on Unsolved Mysteries. A woman claims memories of dying at Pearl Harbor. A murdered husband’s killer resurfaces years later with terrifying threats. A glamorous Las Vegas con artist vanishes after stealing $150,000. And a young clerk disappears without a trace. From reincarnation and hypnosis to extortion, fraud, and unsolved disappearances, this episode explores how the past refuses to stay buried. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support. 👉 Support the show: coff.ee/unsolvedcouple 📧 Email: unsolvedcouplepod@gmail.com 📱 Facebook: Unsolved Couple Podcast 📸 Instagram: @unsolvedcouplepod Original artwork by @evelinejones3 * We’re here to share the stories and spark curiosity, but remember—always do your own digging! Everything we cover is based on public sources, and everyone is considered innocent until proven guilty.

    1h 38m
See All (86)

4.9
out of 5
55 Ratings

About

Unsolved Couple is your weekly throwback to the haunting world of Unsolved Mysteries. Hosts Ben and Sierra revisit the classic cases that gave us chills in the ’90s—disappearances, strange encounters, and stories that still don’t add up. We break down each case with updates, theories, and insights you might have missed, blending nostalgia with today’s true-crime curiosity. Whether you grew up watching Robert Stack or you’re just finding these cases for the first time, join us for mystery, intrigue, and a touch of humor as we unravel the unknown—together. Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/unsolved-couple--6745609/support.

Information

  • Creator
    Unsolved Couple
  • Years Active
    2024 - 2026
  • Episodes
    86
  • Rating
    Clean
  • Copyright
    © Copyright Unsolved Couple
  • Show Website
    Unsolved Couple

You Might Also Like