Why Cart.com spent $5 million on a domain name as their first marketing strategy | Omair Tariq

Cart.com achieved unicorn status in less than three years by pioneering a radically different approach to building a commerce enablement company. Rather than starting from scratch, founder Omair Tariq began with strategic acquisitions - nine companies in the first 14 months - to rapidly assemble the technological and operational infrastructure needed to help mid-market brands sell across multiple channels globally. With a current valuation exceeding $1 billion and revenue approaching half a billion dollars just four years in, Cart.com has created an entirely new category of vertically integrated commerce enablement that bridges venture capital growth with private equity acquisition strategies.

Topics Discussed:

• Cart.com's unconventional founding strategy: acquiring companies before building organically
• The challenge of assembling nine acquisitions in 14 months while building a cohesive company culture
• Evolution of go-to-market strategy from end-to-end messaging to problem-specific approaches
• The talent evolution challenge: transitioning from M&A specialists to company builders
• Marketing strategy evolution from viral brand campaigns to targeted content and education
• Revenue growth from $30M to $180M in year two through combined inorganic and organic growth
• The decision to invest $5M in the Cart.com domain name as a credibility-building marketing strategy

GTM Lessons For B2B Founders:

• Start with the customer's decision-making reality, not your product vision: Cart.com initially pitched their end-to-end commerce solution to CEOs, but discovered that mid-market companies have specialized decision makers. The CMO buys marketing services, the CLO buys logistics, and the CTO buys technology platforms. Omair learned to lead with specific problems for specific decision makers, then cross-sell the broader vision. As he explained: "When we came out with this end-to-end journey, the mid-market was just confused in terms of who would make that decision." B2B founders should map their solution to existing organizational buying patterns rather than expecting customers to change their decision-making structure.
• Perfect your core offering before attempting cross-sells: Cart.com's biggest mistake was trying to cross-sell immature products to existing customers. When they sold Amazon marketplace services before the capability was fully developed, it damaged credibility for their core fulfillment offering. Omair spent months on "apology tours" to repair relationships. The lesson: "Our product and capabilities always have to catch up to our go-to-market motion... you oversell a little bit, but if you do too much of it, then you don't convince them." B2B founders should establish world-class performance in their initial offering before expanding the relationship.
• Reinvent marketing when you're creating a new category: Traditional marketing tactics didn't work for Cart.com's unprecedented value proposition. Trade show booths and paid search ads couldn't communicate their vertical integration story. Instead, they hired marketers who could "invent the playbook" rather than apply existing frameworks. Their head of marketing succeeds because "he doesn't have a playbook, he invents the playbook." B2B founders building novel solutions need marketing talent comfortable with experimentation over expertise.
• Use cross-sell timing as a competitive moat: Cart.com's current strategy involves spending 6-12 months delivering exceptional service in one area before introducing additional capabilities. This patience allows customers to organically request expanded services during strategic business reviews. Omair notes: "When you do the world's best job helping your customers, and they in the back of their mind know there's more you can do, they approach you themselves." This approach creates stronger customer relationships and higher success rates than aggressive early cross-selling.
• Choose investors based on capital, terms, and understanding - not brand: Despite access to tier-one VCs, Cart.com prioritized three factors: maximum capital, best terms, and investor comprehension of their unique model. Omair was skeptical of young associates from large funds: "Do I really want this 26-year-old Stanford grad telling me how to build my company when he or she has never done that before?" For experienced founders, investor brand recognition matters less than practical support and strategic alignment.

//

Sponsors:

Front Lines — We help B2B tech companies launch, manage, and grow podcasts that drive demand, awareness, and thought leadership.

www.FrontLines.io

The Global Talent Co. — We help tech startups find, vet, hire, pay, and retain amazing marketing talent that costs 50-70% less than the US & Europe.

www.GlobalTalent.co