You Can’t Make This BS Up!

Joel

Our podcast delves into a variety of true crime cases, including murder mysteries, high-profile investigations, unsolved crimes, courtroom dramas, serial killers, kidnappings, missing persons, cold cases, and more. We aim to provide a captivating collection of stories that will keep you engaged and eager for the next episode. Get bonus content on Patreon Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

  1. The Shallow Grave Jealousy Trap (57)

    JAN 14

    The Shallow Grave Jealousy Trap (57)

    What happens when a single mom of four tries to move on from a toxic ex… and he decides she can’t? In January 2024, 32-year-old Kayla Laray Atwood drops her kids off at daycare and school in Pensacola, Florida—like any normal day. She never comes back. Her phone goes dark. Her family panics. Police release a chilling photo: Kayla climbing into a yellow Penske truck with a guy she met on a dating app just days earlier. But the real nightmare? Surveillance catches her stepping into her ex-boyfriend Mikhail Fountain’s white pickup truck minutes later. Texts fly between them. Then… nothing. Fountain shows up at neighbors’ doors, begging to see their cameras, claiming Kayla was “kidnapped.” He deletes footage. He wipes messages. He lies to cops. Eight days of agony later, cadaver dogs hit paydirt in the woods near the daycare—Kayla’s body in a shallow grave, shot and buried like trash. Fountain gets arrested at 2 a.m., fighting officers. Motive? Pure, explosive jealousy. Kayla was moving on. Fountain couldn’t handle losing control. Fast-forward to January 2026: After a three-day trial, a jury convicts 36-year-old Mikhail Fountain of second-degree murder. He faces up to life without parole—sentencing coming in February. This is a story of domestic terror, deleted evidence, a mother’s unbreakable love for her four kids, and a cover-up so sloppy you truly can’t make this BS up. Joel Davis breaks it all down: Kayla’s tough Pensacola roots, her family devotion, the tangled ex-boyfriend drama, the heart-stopping search, and the courtroom justice that finally came. Warning: Graphic details of domestic violence and murder. If you’re in danger, call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233. Hit play if you can handle the truth. New episodes drop weekly—subscribe, rate, and review so we can keep exposing stories like this. #TrueCrime #PensacolaMurder #DomesticViolence #YouCantMakeThisBSUp

    31 min
  2. Recorded Rage: The Murder of Rahim Grant by Ciera Harp (53)

    11/21/2025

    Recorded Rage: The Murder of Rahim Grant by Ciera Harp (53)

    Summary This episode delves into the tragic story of Raheem Grant, a talented rapper known as Red Beazzy, who was murdered by his ex-girlfriend Sierra Harp. The narrative explores the complexities of their relationship, the events leading up to the murder, and the subsequent investigation and trial. It highlights themes of jealousy, obsession, and the consequences of toxic relationships, ultimately serving as a cautionary tale about the dangers of manipulation and control in personal connections. Takeaways Raheem Grant was a talented rapper with a promising future. Sierra Harp had a troubled background and manipulative tendencies. The relationship between Raheem and Sierra was marked by control and jealousy. Raheem's mother advised him to document Sierra's erratic behavior. The night of the incident escalated into violence and tragedy. Sierra claimed self-defense, but evidence contradicted her story. Raheem's recorded pleas revealed the truth of the situation. Sierra was convicted of murder and sentenced to 125 years. Family dynamics can complicate perceptions of guilt and innocence. The story serves as a warning about toxic relationships. Sound Bites "You can't make this shit up." "Blood should be thicker than water." "She killed your brother, f**k that." Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Overview of Raheem Grant's Story 05:40 The Rise of Raheem Grant: A Talented Rapper 10:09 Sierra Harp: The Troubled Promoter 15:05 The Relationship Dynamics: Love, Control, and Chaos 17:33 The Night of the Incident: A Fatal Confrontation 22:33 The Aftermath: Investigation and Arrest 23:01 Trial and Sentencing: Justice for Raheem Grant 26:33 Reflections and Lessons Learned 🎙️ Podcast Social & Support ✦ Follow Me Here: 📱 Instagram: @youcantmakethisbsupever 🐦 Twitter/X: @ucmakethisbsup 📘 Facebook: You Can't Make This Bs Up ▶️YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@YouCantMakeThisBSUp 🎧 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3gnPIcP3jY4kT6QSjHClzq?si=c148d81ff7ee406f 🍎 Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/you-cant-make-this-bs-up/id1752624715 ✦ Support the Show: 💸 Venmo: @JDMN2024 💸 Cash App: $youcantmakethisbsup 🍏 Apple Pay: +19128371983 🛒 Merch Store: https://you-cant-make-this-bs-up-shop.fourthwall.com/ ✦ Stay Connected: 🌐 Official Website: https://you-cant-make-this-bs-up-shop.fourthwall.com/ 📧 Contact/Business Inquiries: youcantmakethisbsup@yahoo.com

    30 min
  3. Nancy "Nannie" Doss: The Grandmother that will kill by making you ill PT 2 (52)

    11/10/2025

    Nancy "Nannie" Doss: The Grandmother that will kill by making you ill PT 2 (52)

    Summary This podcast episode delves into the chilling story of Nancy Doss, also known as the Giggling Granny, who allegedly killed at least 11 people, including her husbands and family members. The host, Joel, narrates her life, marriages, and the dark events that led to her becoming a notorious figure in true crime history. The episode explores themes of mental health, societal perceptions of women, and the complexities of Doss's character, ultimately leading to her conviction and life sentence. Takeaways Nancy Doss was known as the Giggling Granny. She allegedly killed at least 11 people. Her motives were tied to her tumultuous relationships. Doss's life reflects societal views on women in the 20th century. Mental health evaluations played a significant role in her trial. The investigation revealed a pattern of suspicious deaths. Doss's confessions were marked by a disturbing nonchalance. She was sentenced to life in prison instead of death. The podcast highlights the complexities of her character. Doss's story raises questions about justice and mental health. Takeaways Nancy Doss was known as the Giggling Granny. She allegedly killed at least 11 people. Her motives were tied to her tumultuous relationships. Doss's life reflects societal views on women in the 20th century. Mental health evaluations played a significant role in her trial. The investigation revealed a pattern of suspicious deaths. Doss's confessions were marked by a disturbing nonchalance. She was sentenced to life in prison instead of death. The podcast highlights the complexities of her character. Doss's story raises questions about justice and mental health. Sound Bites "Happy Veterans Day!" "He had it coming!" "You got me trapped!" Chapters 00:00 Introduction and Veterans Day Tribute 03:58 The Diabolical Story of Nancy Dawes 09:44 Nancy's Marriages and Mysterious Deaths 14:53 The Search for a New Husband 19:32 The Boring Life with Sam Dawes 19:54 The Giggling Granny's Dark Secrets 24:24 The Investigation Unfolds 28:14 Mental Health and Legal Proceedings 32:02 Sentencing and Public Perception 35:03 The Aftermath and Legacy of Nanny Doss 🎙️ Podcast Social & Support ✦ Follow Me Here: 📱 Instagram: @youcantmakethisbsupever 🐦 Twitter/X: @ucmakethisbsup 📘 Facebook: You Can't Make This Bs Up ▶️YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@YouCantMakeThisBSUp 🎧 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/3gnPIcP3jY4kT6QSjHClzq?si=c148d81ff7ee406f 🍎 Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/you-cant-make-this-bs-up/id1752624715 ✦ Support the Show: 💸 Venmo: @JDMN2024 💸 Cash App: $youcantmakethisbsup 🍏 Apple Pay: +19128371983 🛒 Merch Store: https://you-cant-make-this-bs-up-shop.fourthwall.com/ ✦ Stay Connected: 🌐 Official Website: https://you-cant-make-this-bs-up-shop.fourthwall.com/ 📧 Contact/Business Inquiries: youcantmakethisbsup@yahoo.com

    40 min

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
2 Ratings

About

Our podcast delves into a variety of true crime cases, including murder mysteries, high-profile investigations, unsolved crimes, courtroom dramas, serial killers, kidnappings, missing persons, cold cases, and more. We aim to provide a captivating collection of stories that will keep you engaged and eager for the next episode. Get bonus content on Patreon Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

You Might Also Like