Nonprofit Lowdown

Rhea Wong

This is Nonprofit Lowdown where I review and recommend the best ideas, resources, tools, tricks and tips to run your nonprofit like a pro!

  1. 4d ago

    #414 - Your Wealthiest Donors Already Set the Money Aside. Here’s How to Get Picked.

    Wealthy Americans give. Almost every one of them, every single year. If you’re staring down Q4 feeling the squeeze of tariffs, inflation, and the price of eggs, this episode is your good news. Anna Pruitt is a senior vice president and philanthropic strategist with the National Consulting and Advising Practice Group at Bank of America Private Bank. Before that she was managing editor of Giving USA and associate director of research at the IU Lilly Family School of Philanthropy. She describes her move to the bank as coming down from the ivory tower. Now she turns the research into something nonprofits can use, and she talks to a lot of donors along the way. We dig into the 2026 Study of Wealthy Americans, which counts anyone with $5 million or more in investable assets as wealthy. Their top motivations look like everyone else’s: believing they can make a difference, and their personal values. Anna tells the story of a donor who scored beautifully on a wealth screen and said flatly, “I am never going to give more.” His giving went to a health cause tied to his family. No pitch was going to change that. Her fix is a better question: what do you hope your giving will change? Then we get to the next generation. About three-quarters of wealthy Gen Z and Millennial donors receive regular trust distributions. They give to nearly every cause at high rates, and they also mentor, fundraise, and serve on boards. They follow issues more than logos. The number that stopped me: 73% say their social circle shapes their giving, compared with 12% of Boomers and the Silent Generation. Your young board members are your loudest champions. So are your current donors’ kids. On year-end, Anna says to slow down. Only 56% of younger wealthy donors give in cash, compared with 92% overall. The rest give through DAFs, family foundations, and trusts, which means the money is already earmarked and the decision isn’t happening in the last six weeks. Check when each donor has given in the past and ask on their timeline. And ask your volunteers. They give more than non-volunteers. My favorite moment is when Anna says it’s time to stop thinking about the donor pipeline and widen the circle instead. I’ve been calling it the web. People find you on social, land on your site, and join your newsletter, in whatever order they want. They’re not lemmings. If you’ve been treating December 31 as the only deadline that matters, listen to this one first. Close Major Gifts by December 31: Live Workshop Thursday, Nov 19, 1:30 PM ET. Pick your top five donors, write the emails with me, and send them before we log off. $97, 50 seats. Register: https://go.rheawong.com/nov-live-workshop Important Links: 2026 Study of Wealthy Americans (Philanthropy): https://www.privatebank.bankofamerica.com/articles/study-of-wealthy-americans-philanthropy.html Close Major Gifts Workshop: https://go.rheawong.com/nov-live-workshop My Big Ask Gifts Program: https://go.rheawong.com/big-ask-gifts-program My Book, Get That Money Honey: https://go.rheawong.com/get-that-money-honey My Newsletter: https://www.rheawong.com/

  2. Nov 9

    #413 - Stock, DAFs, IRAs: The Year-End Gifts You’re Not Asking For

    Here’s the uncomfortable math. About 97% of wealth sits in non-cash assets. Stock, DAFs, crypto, retirement accounts. And your year-end appeal offers two options: credit card or check. You’re asking for the 3%. Two years ago, only 14% of nonprofits received a single gift from the other 97%. Allison Fine is president and CEO of every.org, a giving platform that is itself a nonprofit. It takes stock, crypto, DAF, and now IRA gifts, liquidates them, and sends the nonprofit cash. It charges nothing. It’s funded by grants and donations, and it was built so a small shop could accept gifts that feel exotic or legalistic. One org on the platform, with a budget under $500,000, has received $115,000 in DAF and stock gifts. We start with the IRA. There’s $18 trillion sitting in IRAs in this country. At 70.5, donors can move up to $115,000 a year straight to charity through a qualified charitable distribution. Except some financial institutions mail the check to the donor and trust it’ll find its way to you. Spoiler: it often doesn’t. Then Allison names your real competition. It’s not the nonprofit down the street. It’s the bank holding the DAF, which is very good at convincing donors to park money there instead of giving it to you. Then we get practical. Your donation page looks like a ransom note, and your stock instructions live in a five-page PDF nobody opens. Younger donors expect giving to work like banking: two clicks and done. Send a one-page giving guide with your EIN and transfer details so donors can forward it to their advisor. And on the back end, Allison’s line is the one I’ll be repeating all season: a tax receipt is not a thank-you note. Then Allison drops a warning I needed to hear. Billionaires are masking the collapse of everyday donors, and first-year retention sits around 19%. I named the tension every under-resourced shop feels: if you’ve got three hours, the six-figure donor wins on ROI. Her answer is that you don’t get to pick one. And it comes down to a bigger question. Are you selling a product, or building a community?  We close on December 31. It matters for your cash, stock, crypto, and IRA givers. It does not matter to your DAF or family foundation donors, so stop pressuring them on your timeline instead of theirs. If your year-end plan is “click here to donate,” this conversation is for you. Important Links: every.org: https://www.every.org Allison Fine: https://www.linkedin.com/in/allison-fine-a07132/  My Big Ask Gifts Program: https://go.rheawong.com/big-ask-gifts-program My Book, Get That Money Honey: https://go.rheawong.com/get-that-money-honey My Newsletter: https://www.rheawong.com/

  3. Nov 2

    #412 - The Year-End Question Nobody’s Asking Donors

    You know the fantasy. You get one meeting with a philanthropic advisor, she sees how good your work is, she walks you into her top five clients, and your year is made. Dr. Vandana Arcot is that advisor. Nonprofits ask her for exactly this all the time. Her answer is “absolutely not.” Dr. Vandana Arcot is a physician who trained in India and then spent two decades with international global health agencies, mostly in reproductive health. She also holds a public health degree and an MBA, and she calls herself a translator between field work and the boards writing the checks. Today she advises high-net-worth donors and family foundations through KOMSELJ, with programs running in 17 countries. We start with her five donor types: the reactive giver, the giver tied to the place that helped them, the “reseeder” who spreads small gifts and comes back to whoever performed, the high-net-worth donor branching into philanthropy full time, and the legacy donor. Each one needs a different approach. Her story about the auditorium shows why. A donor wanted to sponsor one at her mother’s old school. On the field visit, Vandana’s team found the school needed toilets so girls could attend during their periods, plus streetlights so kids could get home safely. Attendance went up 25 to 30%. The donor still got her auditorium. Then we get into what her clients check before they give. Her answer: they give where they trust, and that trust comes from social proof now, not from your email list. The organizations getting surprise checks are “building a room, not a list.” That means small working sessions all year, where existing donors talk about the work and bring their friends along. Her verification process goes past audited financials to field visits, where past donors came from, and the failures you’re willing to name. One finding stung: founder-led nonprofits doing great work in the field rarely come up as the most fundable, because nobody has time to build the proof. On year-end, she says Giving Tuesday is an anchor, not a deadline. Your gala should end with a public impact report, not a gift basket. That means your legal name, your EIN, and what $10,000 and $100,000 actually buy. Link your audited financials in every email you send. And her top tip: stop asking donors how much. Ask when they plan to give, show them what the program costs, and let them decide the amount. My favorite moment is when we both admit the hard part. Doing good work doesn’t mean anyone finds you. I call it shining a diamond in a cave. Nobody’s out there looking for you, so you have to be findable, and for Gen Z donors that means Instagram and TikTok. If your year-end plan is a gala and a prayer, this conversation is for you. Important Links: KOMSELJ : https://www.komselj.com/ Substack : https://substack.com/@drvandanaarcot My Big Ask Gifts Program : https://go.rheawong.com/big-ask-gifts-program My Book, Get That Money Honey : https://go.rheawong.com/get-that-money-honey My Newsletter : https://www.rheawong.com/

  4. Oct 19

    #410 - Why Your Board goes Quiet after Yes

    A board member once read me the riot act because I never told her that a friend of hers had given to our year-end campaign. She was right. I hadn’t closed the loop, and her friend ended up asking her why nobody had thanked them. I still think about that call. I’ve now worked with dozens of boards across the country, and I haven’t met one that didn’t care about the work. What I’ve met are boards that were never told what fundraising is, what happens to the names they hand over, or what they’re supposed to do next. This episode walks through the six reasons I see most often, split into two groups. Three are why board members hesitate: the money feels loaded, they don’t know what to say, and they’re afraid of looking foolish in front of their friends. Three are why they stall: nobody gave them a specific role, nobody explained what happens after an introduction, and nobody closed the loop when a friend gave. The emotional reasons take longer to solve. The structural ones you can fix this month. Here’s where to start. Replace the vague request to “help” with a menu of specific commitments and let each board member choose. Walk them through the process before they’re asked to trust it, so they know their friends can opt out at any point. And when someone gives, tell the board member the same day, then tell the donor what their gift does. Then look at your three most engaged board members and build from them. You don’t have to win over the three who are sitting back. If your board nods along in meetings and then goes quiet, this conversation is for you. Important Links: Free Board Reset The BAG Program⁠⁠ ⁠ ⁠Get That Money, Honey⁠⁠ ⁠ ⁠My Newsletter⁠⁠ ⁠ ⁠Join Our Live Workshop Register for the 2026 Nonprofit Bootcamp (Free Conference) Join Rhea as a keynote speaker!

  5. Oct 12

    #409 - The 5 Financial Red Flags Fundraisers Miss

    I came into this conversation thinking I knew how to raise money. Turns out, I've been fundraising with a broken financial house and didn't notice until Susan DeMarco walked me through it. Susan DeMarco is the CEO of Brand K Partners, an accounting firm that works exclusively with small to mid-size nonprofits. She provides everything from basic bookkeeping to fractional CFO services. She's spent years watching nonprofits celebrate a major gift, then panic when they can't manage the financial complexity that comes with it. In this episode, Susan names the five financial red flags that tank nonprofits, and it's not what you think. Growth without financial infrastructure is the first. Then revenue recognition confusion, fundraisers celebrate the commitment, finance knows it's not recognizable yet. Cash flow is the killer nobody talks about: you can have a $500,000 grant and still run out of money in month three if only 20% arrives upfront. Weak financial controls mean one person is handling deposits and reconciliation, which is a risk nightmare. And the biggest one: finance and development working completely independently, speaking different languages about the same money. Susan's advice cuts straight through. If you're hiring a CFO or finance director, nonprofit experience matters. For-profit accountants don't understand restricted funding the way a nonprofit accountant does. Every grant letter is different, and if your finance person doesn't know that, you're in trouble. Before you celebrate a major gift, ask your finance team: Can we actually manage this? Do we have the infrastructure? If not, the money arrives and your books break. The real kicker is this: fundraising success doesn't automatically equal financial health. It can feel like a win and a crisis at the same time. Susan walks you through what to watch for and the exact moment it's time to bring in outside help instead of hoping your one overworked bookkeeper figures it out. If your ED and your finance person don't talk, or if you're not sure what "revenue recognition" means, this conversation is for you. Important Links: Brand K Partners Susan DeMarco The BAG Program Get That Money, Honey My Newsletter Join Our Live Workshop

  6. Oct 5

    #408 - Email's Hidden Value: Why Donors Wait

    I came into this thinking email was dead. Ben Smithee and Brad Duff-Hudkins from NextAfter walked me back from the ledge with 17 million email subscribers worth of actual data. Spoiler: email is fine. You're just bad at it. Ben Smithee is Chief Growth Officer at NextAfter. Brad Duff-Hudkins is VP of Data & Analytics. Together, they've run 8,000+ experiments on nonprofit email and published research that blows up everything we think we know about donor acquisition and retention. Downstream donors, the ones who take almost 900 days to give their first gift, return $10.29 for every dollar you spend. Instant donors return $2.38. On a list of 1,000 new subscribers, 800 never give. But 100+ become donors over time, many jumping straight to major gift levels. The real move: donors who make a second gift within six months of their first are 40% more likely to give again in year two. Most nonprofits don't have an email strategy. They have a blast. One email a month, then ramped-up asks at year-end. Ben and Brad tested adding a single cultivation email (no ask) on a Saturday to an organization sending one appeal a week. Result: 41% revenue lift, 13% conversion bump, 52% engagement increase. The hard truth: 80% of new donors don't come back. But if you get them to a second gift in the first six months, you've locked in behavior change. You've moved them from transaction to relationship. If you're managing email like a campaign instead of a relationship engine, this conversation is for you. Important Links: NextAfter Research Database : 8,000+ free experiments searchable by nonprofit challenge Email Lifetime Value Study : Full report with all the benchmarks My Big Ask Gifts Program My Book, Get That Money Honey My Newsletter Join the Free Webinar

  7. Sep 28

    #407 - The Gen Z Donor Strategy Nobody's Building

    I'll admit it. I came into this conversation ready to talk about "those damn kids." They give me the blank stare. They call me bro. My friend in staffing says they show up for one day of work and never come back. Phil Putnam walked me back from the ledge. (Mostly. The bro thing still bugs me.) Phil Putnam is a workforce behavior strategist and keynote speaker who spent 20+ years as a team member and executive at Apple and Adobe. Now he helps associations and companies like PCMA, Bloomberg, Slack, and Salesforce understand how different generations work and give. He's a Gen Xer with two Gen Z mentors, ages 26 and 22, and he is unapologetically pro-Gen Z. In this episode, we get into why safety is the North Star for this generation. They've never known life without school shootings, and many of them believe the planet won't outlast them. Phil maps what each generation wants from work: loyalty for boomers, excellence for Gen X, value exchange for millennials, safety for Gen Z. Most fundraising strategies are written by boomers and Xers, through a boomer and Xer lens. For EDs managing Gen Z staff, Phil explains why "bring me a first draft" can feel terrifying to someone raised on teaching to the test. His advice: never lower the job requirements when a Gen Z fundraiser says they hate the phone. Pair the requirement with safety instead. Try it, and I won't punish you for the draft. And if they still won't do the job, find them another role or let them go. Replacing an employee costs roughly 150% of their salary. Then we tackle loyalty. Phil's take: Gen Z is loyal, just not to employment as we know it. The oldest Gen Zer has been working for six years. Layoffs, COVID, AI, more layoffs. Top performers get an average raise of 3.7%. The math doesn't math. On the donor side, Gen Z is 27% of the workforce today and will be 31% by 2035. Forbes 30 Under 30 is almost entirely Gen Z. Phil's approach starts with values alignment: ask what they care about and what they're afraid of, then take their answers at face value. For retention, keep the first gift easy, put your Gen Z donors in the room with your boomers, and connect them to each other. My favorite moment is Phil's welcome email test. You pay an association hundreds of dollars, and the first email asks you to join a committee. It's like ordering dinner and getting handed an apron. His point lands hard for fundraisers: your donors are your customer, not your resource. If your donor strategy only speaks boomer, this conversation is for you. Important Links:Phil Putnam SpeaksEmail Phil: booking@philputnam.com My Big Ask Gifts ProgramMy Book, Get That Money HoneyMy NewsletterJoin the Free Webinar

4.9
out of 5
131 Ratings

About

This is Nonprofit Lowdown where I review and recommend the best ideas, resources, tools, tricks and tips to run your nonprofit like a pro!

You Might Also Like