Dishin' Dirt with Gary Pickren

Gary Pickren

In the Award-Winning Dishin' Dirt with Gary Pickren, South Carolina Real Estate Commissioner/Attorney/Broker/Instructor- Gary Pickren discusses important, timely and relevant topics for South Carolina real estate agents. He covers topics such as the NAR Settlement, Clear Cooperation, agent compensation, "wholesaling", seller disclosure, video marketing, repair addendum, RESPA and much more. All topics are either related to real estate or agency law, marketing or real estate agent best practices.  Gary often interviews top real estate minds such as Leo Pareja (CEO-eXp), James Dwiggins (CEO-NextHome), Gary Gold, Krista Mashore, Jess Lenouvel, Jeff Lobb, Chelsea Peitz, Carl Medford and many more. Gary always tries to bring a touch of humor to each podcast. This is a podcast for every real estate agent in South Carolina regardless how long you have been in the business. Winner of the American Land Title Association 2024 Webbie. Named #1 Best Podcast in South Carolina for Real Estate by FeedSpot and PlayerFM and #7 Best Podcast for REALTORS by MillionPodcast.com. Disclaimer: Our site does not create an attorney-client relationship and it is not intended for detailed legal advice. We are licensed in South Carolina. Any result we achieve on a client’s behalf does not necessarily mean similar results for other clients.  ***DISCLAIMER*** Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your jurisdiction for applicable legal advice germane to your issue. Copyright © Blair | Cato | Pickren | Casterline LLC – All Rights Reserved

  1. 2d ago

    Real Estate's Biggest Brokerages Unite to Fight Private Listings — Will Compass Lose?

    Send us Fan Mail The real estate industry is fighting back against private listing networks. But could the proposed solution create an entirely new problem? Some of America's largest real estate companies—including Keller Williams, eXp Realty, NextHome, RE/MAX, and HomeServices of America—have joined forces to support a new initiative called Open Real Estate. The goal? Keep real estate listing information accessible, protect cooperation between brokerages, and prevent the housing market from becoming divided into competing private listing networks. But there's a twist. Could Open Real Estate actually become another private listing network itself? In this episode of Dishin' Dirt, South Carolina real estate attorney and Real Estate Commissioner Gary Pickren breaks down the new initiative, the growing battle over private listings, and what this could mean for the future of the MLS. WHAT WE COVER: 🏠 1. The Real Estate Industry Fights Back Why major competitors are working together to create Open Real Estate and what they're trying to accomplish. ⚖️ 2. Compass vs. the MLS How the battle over private listing networks is changing the real estate industry—and why the outcome could affect brokerages and agents nationwide. 🔍 3. The Open Real Estate Controversy The proposed platform includes a restricted listing option called Participant View. Could a system designed to promote open access end up creating another form of private listing network? 💰 4. Who Controls Real Estate Listing Data? Who owns the information? Who controls its distribution? And who should benefit financially when listing data generates revenue? 📋 5. South Carolina Real Estate Law and Fiduciary Duties What South Carolina agents and brokers need to understand about limited market exposure, seller consent, advertising requirements, MLS rules, and their fiduciary obligations. 🚨 6. Will Open Real Estate Actually Work? We examine the challenges involving brokerage participation, technology, governance, competition, and whether the new platform will truly benefit consumers. THE BIGGER QUESTION Should a buyer's ability to discover available homes depend on which brokerage represents them? Should sellers be encouraged to restrict exposure to their properties because it benefits a brokerage's business model? And should a handful of national companies have the power to influence how listing information is distributed? These are questions that could shape the future of residential real estate. THE FINAL EPISODE OF OUR FOUR-PART SERIES Over the past several weeks, Dishin' Dirt has examined four major developments affecting the real estate industry: Compass and the growing legal battle with multiple listing services.The Warren–Booker letter urging the FTC to investigate referral fees, mortgage steering, and private listing practices.President Trump's executive order addressing housing affordability.Open Real Estate and the industry's effort to preserve cooperation and access to listing information.All four stories lead to one fundamental question: Who is the real estate industry really supposed to serve—the brokerage, the technology company, or the consumer? 👍 LIKE this video if you found it helpful. 🔔 SUBSCRIBE for weekly real estate news and legal insights. 📤 SHARE this episode with your broker, fellow agents, and anyone following the battle over private listings. Don't forget to like us and share us! Gary * Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your area.

  2. Nov 12

    Trump's New Housing Executive Order: 4 Changes That Could Impact Homebuyers

    Send us Fan Mail President Trump has signed a new executive order aimed at making housing more affordable. But will it actually lower the cost of buying and owning a home? In this episode of Dishin' Dirt, South Carolina real estate attorney and Real Estate Commissioner Gary Pickren breaks down President Trump's October 22, 2026 executive order, Decreasing Housing Costs for the American People, and explains what it could mean for homebuyers, homeowners, lenders, closing attorneys, and real estate agents. The executive order addresses four major areas of housing affordability, including changes to mortgage insurance, manufactured housing, refinancing costs, and certain government-backed housing programs. HERE'S WHAT WE COVER: 🏠 1. Automatic Mortgage Insurance Cancellation Could homeowners save hundreds or even thousands of dollars through automatic PMI cancellation? We examine the proposed pilot program, how it could work, and why it won't immediately apply to every existing mortgage. 🏗️ 2. Making Homes Cheaper to Build The executive order targets regulatory barriers affecting manufactured and factory-built housing. Could reducing unnecessary inspections, approvals, and construction expenses help address America's housing shortage? 📋 3. Title Insurance and Refinancing Costs Could automated title reviews replace traditional lender's title insurance on certain refinances? Gary explains the potential savings, the risks involved, and why eliminating a fee doesn't necessarily eliminate the need for consumer protection. 💰 4. Lower USDA and VA Direct-Loan Interest Rates The order calls for lower interest rates on certain loans made directly by the USDA and VA. But does that mean all veterans and USDA borrowers will receive lower mortgage rates? Not exactly. THE BIGGER QUESTION: WILL ANY OF THIS ACTUALLY WORK? Reducing housing costs sounds great. But what happens when government policies eliminate fees, reduce regulatory requirements, or replace traditional protections with technology? Are consumers genuinely saving money, or are we simply shifting costs and financial risks elsewhere? Gary examines the benefits, potential drawbacks, and practical implications of each proposal, including what South Carolina real estate professionals need to understand before discussing these changes with clients. 👍 LIKE this video if you found it helpful. 🔔 SUBSCRIBE for weekly real estate news and legal insights. 📤 SHARE this episode with a real estate agent, lender, or homeowner who needs to understand these changes. Don't forget to like us and share us! Gary * Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your area.

  3. Nov 5

    Congress Wants Answers: Are Real Estate Buyers Being Misled?

    Send us Fan Mail Are major real estate platforms influencing which agents and mortgage lenders homebuyers use? And are consumers paying more because of hidden financial incentives? In this episode of Dishin' Dirt, South Carolina real estate attorney Gary Pickren examines a letter from U.S. Senators Elizabeth Warren and Cory Booker urging the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to investigate potentially deceptive and anticompetitive practices in the real estate industry. The senators raise serious questions about online real estate referral fees, mortgage steering, affiliated lenders, and private listing networks. Here's what we're breaking down: 🏠 Online Real Estate Referral Fees: When a buyer clicks "Contact Agent" on a real estate website, who actually receives that lead? And how much of the agent's commission might go back to the platform? 💰 The Hidden Cost of Referrals: How referral fees work, whether they affect commission negotiations, and why consumers should understand the financial relationships behind online agent recommendations. 🏦 Mortgage Steering: Are agents being pressured to recommend affiliated or preferred mortgage lenders? We examine how even a small difference in mortgage interest rates could cost buyers thousands of dollars. ⚖️ RESPA Section 8: What's legal, what's prohibited, and why an affiliated business disclosure doesn't automatically eliminate conflicts of interest or legal liability. 🔑 Title and Closing Attorney Referrals: Why similar concerns can arise when financial incentives influence recommendations involving closing attorneys and other settlement-service providers. 📋 South Carolina Fiduciary Duties: Why real estate agents must put their clients' interests first, even when brokerage relationships, referral platforms, or preferred vendors create competing financial incentives. 🏡 Private Listing Networks: How these concerns connect to the growing Compass-versus-MLS controversy and the battle over control of real estate listings. The big question: Is your real estate agent recommending the best professional for YOU, or the one who benefits their brokerage or referral platform? Gary explains the difference between lawful referral arrangements and potentially improper steering, and why brokers-in-charge should be reviewing their policies before regulators come knocking. Important: The Warren–Booker letter requests an FTC investigation. Allegations discussed in this episode are not findings that any other company violated the law. Don't forget to like us and share us! Gary * Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your area.

  4. Oct 29

    Compass vs. 9 MLSs: Real Estate Giants Unite Against Private Listings

    Send us Fan Mail Compass vs. the MLS: The Real Estate War Just Exploded! The battle over who controls America's real estate listings just got a whole lot bigger — and what happens next could change the way homes are bought and sold in South Carolina and across the country. Six major Multiple Listing Services (MLSs) have filed a federal lawsuit against Compass, and at least nine MLS organizations are now pushing back against Compass CEO Robert Reffkin's efforts to challenge MLS rules and expand private listing networks. But that's not all. Keller Williams, AGNT (parent company of eXp Realty and NextHome), HomeServices of America, and Real REMAX Group have announced a major new collaboration called Open Real Estate, supporting broader access to real estate listings. Is this the beginning of an all-out war over who controls the housing market? In this episode of Dishin' Dirt, South Carolina real estate attorney Gary Pickren breaks down the lawsuits, the competing business models, and the potentially enormous consequences for real estate agents, brokers, buyers, and sellers. In this episode, we discuss: Why six MLSs joined forces to sue Compass.Why at least nine MLS organizations are challenging Compass's approach.What Robert Reffkin and Compass want to change about MLS rules.Why Keller Williams, eXp's parent company, HomeServices, and RE/MAX-related leadership are collaborating around open listing distribution.Whether private listing networks actually benefit sellers or primarily benefit large brokerages.How private listings could affect competition, home prices, and fair housing.Why South Carolina's Limited Market Exposure Guidance matters.Whether one national brokerage should be able to challenge the rules of an entire local MLS.What this battle could mean for independent real estate brokerages and fiduciary duties.PLUS: Four major national real estate developments in just ten days! President Trump has signed a new housing affordability executive order, Senators Elizabeth Warren and Cory Booker have called for FTC scrutiny of three controversial real estate practices, MLS organizations are fighting Compass in federal court, and major national brokerages are joining forces around open listing distribution. This episode kicks off a special Dishin' Dirt series leading up to Thanksgiving, examining the national developments that could reshape real estate in South Carolina. THE BIG QUESTION: Should brokerages be allowed to publicly market homes while keeping them off the MLS? Is that seller choice, or does it threaten competition and consumer access to housing? Tell us what you think in the comments! Subscribe to Dishin' Dirt for straight talk about real estate law, industry news, commission practices, fiduciary duties, and the issues affecting real estate professionals. Don't forget to like us and share us! Gary * Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your area.

  5. Oct 22

    Gary Responds to His First Hate Mail

    Send us Fan Mail Gary Responds to His FIRST Hate Mail! | Real Estate Agents, Brokerages & the TRUTH After 300 episodes of Dishin’ Dirt and five years of calling out questionable practices in the real estate industry, Gary Pickren has finally achieved something remarkable… HIS FIRST HATE MAIL! 😂 Well, technically, it was a Facebook post. But who's counting? A South Carolina real estate agent recently accused Gary of throwing her brokerage under the bus and criticizing agents instead of helping them. There's just one problem: Gary never mentioned her brokerage. So what happens when an attorney who has spent 31 years educating and defending real estate professionals gets accused of hurting the very industry he's trying to protect? You get one of the funniest, most sarcastic, and most brutally honest episodes of Dishin’ Dirt yet! In this episode, Gary responds to his first public critic and tackles some uncomfortable truths about the real estate industry: 🔥 Robert Reffkin, Compass & Anywhere: Why criticizing corporate leadership isn't the same as attacking individual agents or Brokerages. 🔥 The $1.78 Billion Commission Verdict: What happens when agents blindly trust the industry's claim that "we've always done it this way." 🔥 Brokerage Loyalty vs. Fiduciary Duty: Who comes first—your client or the company whose logo is on your business card? 🔥 Private Listings & Steering: Why questionable brokerage practices are attracting attention from federal lawmakers. 🔥 The Senate Is Watching: Why Senators Elizabeth Warren and Cory Booker are raising concerns about private listings and affiliated mortgage relationships. 🔥 When Your Broker Is Wrong: Why following company policy doesn't automatically protect your real estate license. 🔥 What Good Attorneys Actually Do: Is your closing attorney supposed to tell you what you want to hear—or what you NEED to hear? And Gary addresses the statement that inspired this entire episode: Real estate attorneys should be "focusing on what's important." Gary couldn't agree more. What's important isn't keeping your brokerage happy. It's protecting your clients, your reputation, your livelihood, and your REAL ESTATE LICENSE. This episode isn't about attacking agents or brokerages. It's about why the real estate industry desperately needs more people willing to tell uncomfortable truths—even when those truths make somebody angry. And if you think Gary is talking about YOUR brokerage… well, you might want to ask yourself why. 😂 THE BOTTOM LINE: Your brokerage may sign your commission check, but your real estate license has YOUR name on it. 👇 JOIN THE CONVERSATION! Have you ever disagreed with your broker's policies? Do you think industry leaders should be publicly criticized when their decisions put agents at risk? Is speaking uncomfortable truths helping the industry—or hurting it? Drop your thoughts in the comments. Gary welcomes disagreement. Just make sure you actually listen to the episode first! 👍 LIKE this video if you believe agents deserve the truth. 🔔 SUBSCRIBE to Dishin’ Dirt for real estate law, industry news, and the conversations other people are afraid to have. 📤 SHARE this episode with an agent who needs to hear it! ABOUT GARY PICKREN Gary Pickren is a South Carolina real estate attorney, member of the South Carolina Real Estate Commission, ARELLO Certified Instructor, and host of Dishin’ Dirt. With more than 31 years of experience, Gary delivers real estate education, legal insights, and industry commentary without the corporate Kool-Aid. Don't forget to like us and share us! Gary * Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your area.

  6. Oct 15

    Compass vs. MLS: Robert Reffkin's Legal War Could Change Real Estate Forever

    Send us Fan Mail Compass CEO Robert Reffkin is taking on the MLS system—and California Regional MLS (CRMLS) just fought back with a federal lawsuit. But this battle could change how real estate is bought and sold across America. Is this really about seller choice, or is Compass trying to force the entire real estate industry to operate under its preferred rules? In this explosive episode of Dishin' Dirt, South Carolina real estate attorney Gary Pickren breaks down the escalating battle between Compass and California Regional MLS, including Reffkin's threats of antitrust lawsuits, his controversial appearance before MLS executives, and CRMLS's decision to take the fight to federal court. But the bigger question is what happens if Compass wins. Could one national brokerage force local MLS organizations across the country to change their cooperation rules—even when the other participating brokers disagree? And could the consequences eventually reach South Carolina? In this episode, we cover: Why Compass threatened California Regional MLS with antitrust litigationWhat happened when Robert Reffkin confronted MLS executives at a national conferenceWhy CRMLS filed a federal lawsuit against CompassThe controversy surrounding Compass private listings, office exclusives, and coming-soon marketingWhy Compass wants greater control over how MLS data is distributedThe potential contradiction between Compass's demands for listing freedom and its efforts to restrict certain uses of MLS dataHow a Compass victory could affect MLS organizations nationwideWhy independent brokerages and smaller real estate companies should pay attentionThe potential consequences for buyers, sellers, competition, and listing transparencyWhat South Carolina real estate agents need to understand about fiduciary duties and limited market exposureTHE BIG QUESTION: If Robert Reffkin wants Compass to operate differently, that's his business. But should one brokerage be able to force every other broker's MLS to operate the way Compass wants? This isn't just a California lawsuit. It's a battle over who controls real estate listings, who establishes the rules of cooperation, and whether the future of real estate will be an open cooperative marketplace or a collection of brokerage-controlled listing networks. The outcome could affect every real estate professional in America. What do YOU think? Should Compass be allowed to publicly market listings outside the MLS while continuing to benefit from the listings other brokers contribute? Or should MLS organizations be allowed to enforce reciprocal cooperation rules? Tell me in the comments. I want to hear from agents, brokers, MLS executives, and consumers. 👍 LIKE this video if you believe real estate professionals need to understand this issue. 💬 COMMENT with your opinion on the Compass vs. MLS battle. 🔔 SUBSCRIBE for real estate legal analysis, industry controversies, South Carolina real estate law, and the issues shaping the future of real estate. Gary's Series Before You Can Sign can be found here. https://www.youtube.com/@SCPropertyEstate This episode provides legal commentary and analysis. Allegations in pending litigation are disputed and have not been established by a final court ruling. #Compass #RobertReffkin #CRMLS #RealEstateNews #RealEstateLaw #MLS #PrivateListings #DishinDirt #SouthCarolinaRealEstate Don't forget to like us and share us! Gary * Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your area.

  7. Oct 8

    Dumb $#!% Real Estate Agents Say — Part 2

    Send us Fan Mail Real estate agents say a lot of things with confidence. The problem is, confidence does not make something true. In this episode of Dishin’ Dirt, Gary Pickren breaks down 10 of the dumbest, most dangerous, and most commonly repeated things real estate agents say—and explains why they can create legal problems, contract disputes, ethics issues, and bad outcomes for clients. We cover: • “It’s Coming Soon, so some buyers can see it but others can’t.” • “You have to guarantee buyer-agent compensation.” • “Our standard commission is…” • “We terminated during due diligence, we just didn’t send the termination fee.” • “Don’t send me the inspection report because I don’t want to know.” • Why the argument for private exclusives gets harder to defend when most eventually end up on the MLS anyway. • “I don’t know if the earnest money was ever deposited.” • “The appraisal came in low, so the seller has to lower the price.” • “The seller has to fix it because it’s not up to code.” • And the classic: “Don’t worry about what the contract says. We do it this way all the time.” The common theme is simple: real estate professionals have to stop repeating bad information just because they heard another agent say it. Read the contract. Know the law. Understand your agency duties. Explain the options. And when you do not know the answer, say, “I don’t know. Let me find out.” That answer is a lot safer than confidently giving your client the wrong one. If you are a real estate agent, broker, lender, closing attorney, buyer, or seller, this episode will help you understand the mistakes that can derail a transaction—and how to avoid them. Subscribe to Dishin’ Dirt for more real estate law, contracts, risk management, industry news, and practical advice for real estate professionals. Don't forget to like us and share us! Gary * Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your area.

  8. Oct 1

    Fiduciary Duty: The Rule Real Estate Loves to Talk About—and Hates to Follow

    Send us Fan Mail Real estate agents talk constantly about fiduciary duty—loyalty, disclosure, reasonable care and putting the client's interests first. But does the real estate industry actually practice what it teaches? In this episode of Dishin' Dirt, Gary Pickren takes a hard look at the conflicts between fiduciary duty and the way real estate professionals actually make money. The Sitzer/Burnett case was an antitrust case, but the compensation system it challenged raises a much bigger question: Was guaranteeing buyer-agent compensation really in the seller's best interest—or was it simply good for the industry? And after Sitzer, have we really changed? Gary examines: • Broker-to-broker compensation and why South Carolina REALTORS changed its forms • Whether compensation should be negotiated as part of the offer • Private and office-exclusive listings • The South Carolina Real Estate Commission's limited-market-exposure guidance • Research comparing private listings with broadly marketed properties • Why brokerages want to control listings and consumer data • Dual agency and the financial incentive to capture both sides • Steering, affiliated services and other everyday conflicts of interest • Why getting a client's signature isn't necessarily informed consent • Why "it's legal" isn't the same as "it's in my client's best interest" • What the next generation of real estate litigation could look like Throughout the episode, Gary proposes one simple test every real estate professional should use: WHO BENEFITS? And an even harder question: If your compensation disappeared from the decision, would you give your client the exact same advice? Because fiduciary duty isn't really tested when doing the right thing also makes you money. It's tested when putting your client first costs you something. If the real estate industry wants consumers to view agents as trusted advisors, this is a conversation we need to have. 🎙️ Dishin' Dirt with Gary Pickren Subscribe for straight talk about South Carolina real estate law, agency, contracts, compensation, lawsuits, industry changes and the issues affecting real estate professionals and consumers. Don't forget to like us and share us! Gary * Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your area.

5
out of 5
84 Ratings

About

In the Award-Winning Dishin' Dirt with Gary Pickren, South Carolina Real Estate Commissioner/Attorney/Broker/Instructor- Gary Pickren discusses important, timely and relevant topics for South Carolina real estate agents. He covers topics such as the NAR Settlement, Clear Cooperation, agent compensation, "wholesaling", seller disclosure, video marketing, repair addendum, RESPA and much more. All topics are either related to real estate or agency law, marketing or real estate agent best practices.  Gary often interviews top real estate minds such as Leo Pareja (CEO-eXp), James Dwiggins (CEO-NextHome), Gary Gold, Krista Mashore, Jess Lenouvel, Jeff Lobb, Chelsea Peitz, Carl Medford and many more. Gary always tries to bring a touch of humor to each podcast. This is a podcast for every real estate agent in South Carolina regardless how long you have been in the business. Winner of the American Land Title Association 2024 Webbie. Named #1 Best Podcast in South Carolina for Real Estate by FeedSpot and PlayerFM and #7 Best Podcast for REALTORS by MillionPodcast.com. Disclaimer: Our site does not create an attorney-client relationship and it is not intended for detailed legal advice. We are licensed in South Carolina. Any result we achieve on a client’s behalf does not necessarily mean similar results for other clients.  ***DISCLAIMER*** Gary serves on the South Carolina Real Estate Commission as a Commissioner. The opinions expressed herein are his opinions and are not necessarily the opinions of the SC Real Estate Commission. This podcast is not to be considered legal advice. Please consult an attorney in your jurisdiction for applicable legal advice germane to your issue. Copyright © Blair | Cato | Pickren | Casterline LLC – All Rights Reserved

You Might Also Like