Stories I Wouldn't Tell My Nana

Emmi Abel-Rutter

Sex, Shrooms, Sharks, & so much more.  Tune in as I spill the tea & share all of the stories that I WOULDN'T tell my Nana.

Episodes

  1. May 17

    #6 - Handies are SO BACK (Alaska)

    Send us Fan Mail First of all - this episode is in NO WAY Nana approved. Truly, if we're: related, have a a professional relationship, or you're prone to saying "TMI" - don't listen to this. This is ...explicit. As I'm sitting at LAX on a 7 hour layover, we're unpacking the first 2 weeks of a 5 week trip, in the spring of 2026. Recorded on April 29, 2026 - we talk about...meeting JVN at LAX, my experience performing in the Alaska B4UDie Comedy Festival, housesitting two pups in Anchorage, and unpacking why hand stuff is SO BACK (featuring a throwback to my high school stats - yikes). Also, there's a section of there where I'm talking FERAL - it's been two weeks, and I would like to publicly rescind that. Enjoy 3 xx Emmi Thank you for listening! Website: PotatoComedy.com IG:  PotatoWithMakeup TikTok: PotatoWithMakeup

    2h 21m

  2. May 17

    #5 - The Rutter Girls ft. Zoe & Avery

    Send us Fan Mail In this episode, I sit down with my two younger sisters, Zoe & Avery, as we discuss our unique family dynamic - four siblings, each born 6 years apart, with 3 different combos of bio parents.  I was raised in Cincinnati, OH, 8 hours away from my dad, step-mom, & 3 sisters.  We were all raised differently, and have completely distinct outlooks on our childhood. We dive into Zoe's competitive cheer lore & the accident that changed her life, diving head first into hobbies (cough consumerism cough), parent dynamics... A part of me broke & healed at the same time hearing my little sister say, "I wish you grew up with us." We laugh, I cry, and our dad makes a guest appearance to tell one of our family-favorite stories.  Take a peek into my family life, and add another piece to the Emmi puzzle. Recorded Dec 2024 Thank you for listening! Website: PotatoComedy.com IG:  PotatoWithMakeup TikTok: PotatoWithMakeup

    1h 25m

  3. May 17

    #4 - Shrooms in Aruba

    Send us Fan Mail One of my all-time FAVORITE travel stories. From beginning to end - oversleeping, befriending strangers, following the vibes, meeting a man, & untangling my religious knots - it's Emmi coded. Come along with me as I take you through my day of finding my friends in a hidden alcove in Aruba & trying Shrooms for the first time. Enjoy! Recorded Dec 2023 or 2024 - who knows. Thank you for listening! Website: PotatoComedy.com IG:  PotatoWithMakeup TikTok: PotatoWithMakeup

    1h 28m

  4. 12/27/2025

    #3 - Cage Diving w Great Whites

    Send us Fan Mail Welcome back! On this episode, we dive into the Great White Cage Diving experience with Calypso Star Charters in Port Lincoln, South Australia in 2016. This was one of my first solo trips & clearly, a memorable one. We talk about the logistics of traveling to Port Lincoln, how i spent my time in Adelaide, & the reality of the cage diving experience.  If you prefer adventure stories over Sex & Shrooms - this is a great place to start. This episode is (believe it or not) PG* *"I do cuss a little" - Miranda Cosgrove Thank you for listening! Website: PotatoComedy.com IG:  PotatoWithMakeup TikTok: PotatoWithMakeup

    42 min

  5. 12/26/2025

    #2 - Lads Night

    Send us Fan Mail Welcome back to Stories I Wouldn't Tell My Nana! Our first 3 episodes are diving into Sex, Shrooms, & Sharks - and you guessed it, we're starting you off with a juicy one. We're transported into small(ish) town Australia, on a solo night out - I went out looking for a great night...and I found it. This is the story of one of my favorite one-night stands.  Nana, PLEASE DON'T LISTEN TO THIS. Everyone else - enjoy! Thank you for listening! Website: PotatoComedy.com IG:  PotatoWithMakeup TikTok: PotatoWithMakeup

    1h 53m

  6. 12/13/2025

    #1 - Syllabus Week

    Send us Fan Mail Welcome, welcome to STORIES I WOULDN'T TELL MY NANA. Not only kicking off the season, but kicking off the POD...it's syllabus week! This week I'll be welcoming you to my corner of the internet, how this podcast came about and the WHY behind it, I'll introduce you to the two matriarchs that have inspired me - Nana & GG - and fill you in on what to expect moving forward.  Thank you for being here - enjoy & CHEERS. These are the Stories I Wouldn't Tell My Nana.  Thank you for listening! Website: PotatoComedy.com IG:  PotatoWithMakeup TikTok: PotatoWithMakeup

    1h 11m
  • 6 Episodes

Ratings & Reviews

5
out of 5
3 Ratings

About

Sex, Shrooms, Sharks, & so much more.  Tune in as I spill the tea & share all of the stories that I WOULDN'T tell my Nana.

Information

  • Creator
    Emmi Abel-Rutter
  • Years Active
    2025 - 2026
  • Episodes
    6
  • Rating
    Explicit
  • Copyright
    © 2026 Stories I Wouldn't Tell My Nana
  • Show Website
    Stories I Wouldn't Tell My Nana

You Might Also Like