234 episodes

We take you behind police lines. Former FBI profiler Jim Clemente & former federal prosecutor Francey Hakes get unparalleled access to law enforcement officers, looking back at their most memorable cases – for better or for worse.

Best Case Worst Case Wondery

    • True Crime
    • 4.2 • 2.3K Ratings

We take you behind police lines. Former FBI profiler Jim Clemente & former federal prosecutor Francey Hakes get unparalleled access to law enforcement officers, looking back at their most memorable cases – for better or for worse.

    227 | In Defense Of Oscar Pistorius

    227 | In Defense Of Oscar Pistorius

    Jim and Francey welcome forensic expert and owner of the Evidence Room, Scott Roder, for a spirited discussion about the role he played as an expert witness in the controversial murder trial of Oscar Pistorius

    • 34 min
    226 | Wildest Dreams

    226 | Wildest Dreams

    The case of a violent assault against a Las Vegas sex worker hits a wall...until Sergeant Jim Young has a dream that breaks it wide open

    • 39 min
    149 | Pursuing A Predator

    149 | Pursuing A Predator

    Big John McCarthy sits his first stake out hunting a serial rapist in Hollywood. Will he catch the slippery criminal?

    • 36 min
    Call Me God: The Untold Story of the DC Sniper Investigation

    Call Me God: The Untold Story of the DC Sniper Investigation

    Call Me God is the never-before-told story of the fascinating and turbulent investigation that led to the diabolical and elusive killers' capture; one that pitted protocol against instinct, sacred institutions against individual insight. Told firsthand by those few who had the vision and expertise to solve it, and including a fascinating look into the behavioral, ballistic, forensic, and electronic analysis vital to cracking the case, FBI agent brothers Jim Clemente (former FBI behavioral profiler) and Tim Clemente (former FBI counter-terrorism expert) take us through every facet and flaw of a nationwide manhunt that pressure tested nearly every aspect of law enforcement capabilities—and its glaring vulnerabilities.

    • 3 min
    225 | The Fantastic Mr Fitz

    225 | The Fantastic Mr Fitz

    Jim and Francey welcome returning guest and Best Case Worst Case fan favorite, retired FBI Supervisory Special Agent/Criminal Profiler/Forensic Linguist James R. Fitzgerald

    • 32 min
    224 | Interview With America's Most Wanted Host Elizabeth Vargas

    224 | Interview With America's Most Wanted Host Elizabeth Vargas

    Jim and Francey sit down for a conversation with the wonderful Elizabeth Vargas, host of the all-new America's Most Wanted on FOX

    • 20 min

Customer Reviews

4.2 out of 5
2.3K Ratings

2.3K Ratings

Julie Tampa ,

Compelling insightful must listen podcast

I can’t take Francey anymore. Her interruptions which add nothing - her voice itself is annoying - and she’s usually so off subject with her dumb comments and showing off her knowledge she ruins the cadence of the story at least 2-3 times every show. And then as a former prosecutor -she’s shocked that a woman who worked in the sex industry who was brutally assaulted- didn’t want to talk to police or press charges? Are you kidding me?. Out of every 1000 sexual assaults - 995 perpetrators walk free! Why would a victim go through the abuse of not being believed by the police and prosecution? There’s very few jurisdictions in this entire country (and world wide) where women are believed by police, their rape kits are tested, their cases are investigated, and prosecutors actually prosecute. If it even does get to a prosecutor, If they deign to charge - they just plea bargain most sexual felonies down to
MisdemeanorS. Thanks prosecutors. Jim gets it. Francey please do some research. Almost 90% of sexual assaults are by someone known to the victim and police and prosecutors don’t like those kind of cases. And the victim gets assaulted again by the criminal justice system. Jim is a much better - more educated advocate for women.

Deep Space Explorer ,

I love Francey! She makes this podcast great

I absolutely love what Francey brings to this, the legal side and humor and questions, and Jim complements with the BAU and great stories. Sometimes Jim is pretty rude sounding with his humor, but it’s typical police-type banter (I know from working in the field). It’s often offensive-sounding and over the line and yeah it’d be better if they could be a little more OBVIOUSLY friendly jokes, but the banter is great so don’t get rid of it maybe just try to let people know you’re joking and do appreciate her :-). Jim usually can’t take a joke when it’s directed at him so he feels the need to defend himself, that’s just who he is. I think he gets nervous that people will assume a joke is true so he has to “correct” it, which I personally think makes him look like he has a sensitive ego, but it is what it is.

I don’t get the comments about Francey’s voice...she has a great voice and I love her style, tone, and disposition. Don’t change it Francey!

I LOVE the flow of the podcast and the questions both Jim and Francey ask are spot on, and help me learn about techniques and really guide the story better than just letting the guest tell their story. Another review said to stop asking questions, but PLEASE don’t do that! People aren’t great storytellers, especially not as great as Francey who does great storytelling in court that for her career and KNOWS how to communicate properly, so it really helps for Jim and Francey to keep them on track and pull out the details of the story that we cafe about. Don’t change a thing about the show! I live the banter between the two of them and their guests, and it would not be the same show with Francey and Jim together, just great.

PeteMT ,

Please

Can you please let the guest finish talking before you interrupt them to ask them exactly what they were about to tell us? Great show besides that!

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Listeners Also Subscribed To

More by Wondery