Episode 152 The Reading Wars: Disclaimer I am FIRMLY progressive/on the left. Phonics WORKS. THIS IS A FACT. I cannot BELIEVE anyone considered otherwise. To the hosts: Republicans were right about this. GET OVER IT. You're making us all look incredibly ignorant! This is raw milk and Make America Healthy Again levels of anti-science.
I'm childfree so it was a shock to learn that phonics was removed from curriculum. I assumed that's what was being taught the past 20-30 years. To hear these two try to "both sides" this thing is shocking. The level of second-hand embarrassment I feel from each assertion that comes out of their mouths is indescribable.
The NAACP as well as other civil rights organizations have been pushing for reimplementation of phonics, as they realized (you'll never believe this) it was actually marginalized, poc, and lower income students who suffered the MOST from the "balanced", 3 cueing approach.
I genuinely don't understand how anyone in education thought this could remotely be a good idea. Just guess at the word and hope it's right? Look at the first letter and a picture? How could they ever read a person's name or hope to learn new vocabulary organically if they are just guessing?
These hosts are the reason everyone thinks the left is insufferable. Contrarian, pretentious, and self-righteous, bathing in their self-proclaimed intelligence and moral superiority. The male host over here really channels RFK Jr with phrases like the "so-called" science of reading. Are they willfully ignorant? Do they just enjoy being contrarian? Or were they too, victims of the whole language learning model. The world may never know., but I won't be listening to find out.