Working Within a Broken Insurance System: Payer Scrutiny, Claim Denials, and Value-Based Care in Private Practice - An Interview with Sheetal Shah and Shehzad Moiz of SimplePractice Sheetal Shah and Shehzad Moiz of SimplePractice on mental health insurance, claim denials, and value-based care. Curt and Katie talk with Sheetal Shah, who leads payer, employer, and health system partnerships at SimplePractice, and Shehzad Moiz, VP of Product Management for revenue cycle management, about the state of mental health insurance for private practice therapists. They dig into why payers are scrutinizing claims and session length more closely, how insurers are using AI, and what value-based care could look like in mental health. Katie also asks the question many clinicians are asking: whether working with insurance means propping up a broken system. Sheetal and Shehzad talk through credentialing on your own versus joining platforms like Alma and Headway, decoding claim denials, owning your directory profile, and how SimplePractice decides which payers it will and won't partner with. This is a useful conversation for therapists who take insurance, are thinking about getting paneled, or are trying to figure out what payer mix makes sense for their practice. This episode is part of our partnership with SimplePractice. As part of that agreement, we get to ask the hard questions, and our discussion and opinions are our own. In this episode, we discuss: - Why payer scrutiny of codes like 90837 is increasing, and what's driving it - How documentation and outcome measures like the PHQ-9 and GAD-7 can protect your practice - Where value-based care is likely to start in mental health - How credentialing tools differ from platforms like Alma and Headway - What to do when a claim denial code doesn't make sense - Why owning your profile, license, and contracts protects your independence - How to think about participating in an insurance system you don't fully trust Timestamps: - 05:43 - The current mental health insurance landscape - 11:06 - Why payers are scrutinizing 90837 and session length - 16:14 - How insurance companies are using AI - 18:56 - Is partnering with insurance propping up a broken system? - 24:25 - What value-based care could look like in mental health - 27:01 - Credentialing without giving up your independence - 30:15 - Decoding claim denials and disappearing claims - 32:18 - Structural advocacy and owning your profile - 34:10 - How SimplePractice chooses payer partners, and its no-gos - 37:53 - Insurance Essentials, Insurance Navigator, and SimpleConnect Guest Bios: Sheetal Shah brings 20 years of experience in AI, digital health, and health IT, with leadership roles at Woebot, SymphonyRM, Microsoft/Accenture, and the NIH/NIAID. At SimplePractice, he leads payer, employer, and health system commercial partnerships that broaden mental health access. Shehzad Moiz brings 15+ years of experience in product strategy, fintech, and health tech, with leadership roles at Navan and Expedia. As VP Product Management at SimplePractice, he leads product for revenue cycle management, including insurance and payments, helping behavioral health clinicians get paid faster and spend less time on billing. Full show notes and transcript: https://mtsgpodcast.com Join the Modern Therapist Community Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/c/mtsgpodcast Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/therapyreimagined Modern Therapist's Survival Guide Creative Credits Voice Over by DW McCann: https://www.facebook.com/McCannDW/ Music by Crystal Grooms Mangano: https://groomsymusic.com/