Red Flags and Body Bags

Red Flags and Body Bags

Red Flags & Body Bags is the true crime podcast where charming turns chilling--- fast. We break down the crimes, the cover-ups, and the red flags that were waving long before the first body hit the floor. From "nice guy" partners to high-profile lies and hidden motives, we expose the darkness hiding in plain sight. Hosted by a true crime-obsessed couple with just enough sarcasm and side-eye to survive the horror. Because sometimes... the biggest red flag is holding your hand.

  1. Elli Perkins: When Scientology Refused Schizophrenia Treatment

    May 21

    Elli Perkins: When Scientology Refused Schizophrenia Treatment

    Minds in the Mirror Ep 3: Faith Over Medicine – When Scientology Refused Schizophrenia Treatment In this powerful episode of Minds in the Mirror: Mental Health & Murder, we examine one of the most heartbreaking cases where religious ideology clashed with medical reality. On March 13, 2003, Elli Perkins — a talented glass artist and devoted Scientologist — was brutally murdered by her 28-year-old son Jeremy. He st*bbed her 77 times in their family kitchen. Jeremy suffered from severe, untreated paranoid schizophrenia. For years he had been hearing voices and experiencing dangerous delusions, but his mother refused psychiatric care and antipsychotic medication because of Scientology’s longstanding opposition to psychiatry. Instead, Elli turned to the church’s “vitamin protocols,” natural healers, and spiritual auditing — believing she was protecting her son. What followed was a devastating tragedy that could have been prevented. We dive deep into: Jeremy’s years of escalating symptoms and missed red flagsThe 2001 arrest and court-ordered diagnosis that was ignoredHow Scientology’s doctrine shaped the family’s decisionsThe brutal details of the attack and Jeremy’s confessionThe heartbreaking irony: medication later stabilized Jeremy after years of institutional careThis episode explores the dangerous intersection of faith, untreated mental illness, and the refusal of evidence-based treatment — and what we can learn today about recognizing red flags when ideology overrides medicine. Resources mentioned in the episode: National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) Helpline: 1-800-950-NAMIIf you or someone you love is struggling with hallucinations, paranoia, delusions, or schizophrenia symptoms, please reach out. Early intervention can save lives. Drop your biggest takeaway in the comments: When should faith step aside for medical care? #MindsInTheMirror #Scientology #Schizophrenia #MentalHealthAndMurder #TrueCrime #UntreatedMentalIllness #ElliPerkins

    19 min
  2. Josh Davis: Garner North Carolina Cold Case

    May 18

    Josh Davis: Garner North Carolina Cold Case

    On January 6, 2004, 16-year-old Josh Davis was brutally killed while walking in his own neighborhood in Vandora Village, Garner, North Carolina. For 22 years his family waited for answers. Now, in this powerful and emotional episode, Josh’s sister Alyssa Hatcher joins us for her most in-depth interview to date. She shares memories of her big brother, the devastating impact of his murder on their family, and her thoughts on the recent bombshell developments involving a decorated local police detective. In 2026, Megan Bess Potter — a Four Oaks Police Department detective who attended Garner High with Josh and even signed his funeral guest book — was named a person of interest. Search warrants were executed, her devices were seized, and the case is once again active. Alyssa talks openly about learning these shocking details, her hope that those responsible will come forward, and what real closure would mean after more than two decades. Content Warning: This episode discusses the murder of a child and contains emotional family testimony. Listener discretion is advised. No charges have been filed. The investigation by Garner PD and the North Carolina State Bureau of Investigation remains active. If you have any information about Josh Davis’s death on January 6, 2004: Contact Det. Michael Hammerstein, Garner Police Investigations: 919-772-8810 Anonymous tips are welcome.This is more than a cold case — it’s a family still fighting for answers and a community still searching for truth.

    30 min
  3. Slender Man Made Me Do It

    May 14

    Slender Man Made Me Do It

    On May 31, 2014, in the woods of David's Park in Waukesha, Wisconsin, two twelve-year-old girls did the unthinkable. They lured their best friend, twelve-year-old Payton Leutner, into the trees under the pretense of playing hide-and-seek… then stabbed her 19 times with a kitchen knife. Their motive? To become “proxies” for Slender Man — a fictional internet horror character they discovered through creepypasta. What started as an innocent sleepover spiraled into one of the most chilling true crime cases of the 21st century. In this episode of Red Flags and Body Bags, we unpack the full story: the months of secret planning, the girls’ terrifying obsession with the online myth, the brutal attack, the disturbing interrogation tapes, the psychological red flags that were missed, the trials, and the long-term impact on everyone involved. We also examine the bigger questions this case still raises more than a decade later — how powerful online fiction can be on young, vulnerable minds and where the line between internet lore and real-world violence gets blurred. If you love deep-dive true crime with a focus on the warning signs, this one is for you. Mental Health Resources (available to anyone, anywhere in the US):• 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline → Call or text 988 (24/7, free & confidential)• Crisis Text Line → Text HOME to 741741 If you or someone you know is struggling, these national resources are here for you anytime. What do you think — how much blame does the internet deserve in a case like this? Drop your thoughts in the comments or leave a review. #SlenderMan #SlenderManStabbing #WaukeshaStabbing #Creepypasta #TrueCrimePodcast #RedFlagsAndBodyBags

    22 min

Ratings & Reviews

4.6
out of 5
9 Ratings

About

Red Flags & Body Bags is the true crime podcast where charming turns chilling--- fast. We break down the crimes, the cover-ups, and the red flags that were waving long before the first body hit the floor. From "nice guy" partners to high-profile lies and hidden motives, we expose the darkness hiding in plain sight. Hosted by a true crime-obsessed couple with just enough sarcasm and side-eye to survive the horror. Because sometimes... the biggest red flag is holding your hand.

You Might Also Like