I Should Totally Be Dead Right Now Podcast

I Should Totally Be Dead Right Now

Friends Caitlyn and Michelle drink and tell true stories of people who survived crime, natural disasters and everything else in between. On this bi-weekly podcast, we tell new stories each episode along with discussions and a little banter. We have a special drink each time, so grab a glass and join us! Let’s cheers to these amazing survivors as they should totally be dead right now.

  1. 6D AGO

    Episode 189: A Failed System

    This week we talk about Tracey Morgan, a young woman working at the Naval base. She befriends a coworker who is a bit of a loner. Shortly after she begins to see him everywhere she goes. He starts parking outside her house and her personal items begin to disappear and reappear at work. This is just the beginning of years of stalking Tracey has to endure. Listen to how she survived now! Drink of the Week: Caitlyn's Spicy Peach Lemonade

    43 min

  2. MAR 16

    Episode 188: A Taken Opportunity

    This week we talk about Cindy Paulson, a seventeen year old who gets into the car of a serial killer. She finds herself handcuffed and tied to a coffee table. She knows she has to find a way out before getting on a plane with this psychopath. We also talk about the origin story of St.Patrick. He was enslaved and taken to Ireland where he spent six years before his escape. Listen to how they survived now! Drink of the Week: Homemade Irish Cream

    41 min

  3. MAR 2

    Episode 187: Small But Mighty

    This week we talk about Steven Rice. A family man taking a jog, when a small rock gets into his shoe. That small wound will make him end up in the E.R. fighting for his life. We also talk about the Jigsaw Puzzle Club, a group of prisoners in World War II that would get maps smuggled into the prisons. These would help them escape and save their lives! Listen to how they survived now! Drink of the Week: Boozy Root Beer

    43 min

  4. FEB 16

    Episode 186: Saint Valentine's Day

    This week we talk about the Saint Valentine's Day Massacre. We take a deep dive into the history and what happened in the investigation. Who was responsible? Who survived? We cover it all! We also talk about a couple going on a Valentine's Day hike in the snow. They quickly realize they got off the path and are lost. Listen to how they survived now! Drink of the WeeK: Raspberry Paloma

    51 min

  5. FEB 2

    Episode 185: A Step Too Far

    This week we talk about Michael Brewer, a 15 year old being bullied by a few classmates. One day at his apartment complex the bullies take it a step too far and light him on fire. We also talk about Darryle Jacob See, a runner out for a jog. He had his music at full volume, so he didn't see or hear the train approaching at over 100mph. Listen to how they survived now! Drink of the Week: Green Tea Mojito

    44 min

  6. JAN 19

    Episode 184: Overcome

    This week we talk about the McDonough family. The daughter leaves the backdoor unlocked for her brother when he comes home late. This night a different person enters the family's home and is harmed with several knives. We also talk about Cliff Young, a 61 year old farmer. He hears about Australia's ultra marathon, which is 544 miles long. He goes into the race with zero prep or plan. Listen to how they survived now! Drink of the Week: Julene's Sake

    45 min

  7. JAN 5

    Episode 183: A New Me

    Happy New Year! This week we talk about Prosper, a young man who gets into the wrong crowd after his father is killed. On the anniversary if his death, he gets into a fight that turns almost fatal. We also talk about Matthew Greene, a man trying to better himself for the New Year. He goes to the Cairngorm plateau to get a workout in. Unfortunately the weather turns quickly and he gets lost in a blizzard. Listen to how they survived now! Drink of the Week: Gin and Tonic

    48 min

  8. 12/22/2025

    Episode 182: Christmas Vacation

    This week we talk about Nicole and Diana Schoo. Two young girls, 9 and 4 years old, are left home alone at Christmas as their parents go on vacation. We also talk about a group of friends going skiing on Christmas Eve. While they are enjoying the day, an avalanche surprises them. After a quick headcount they are missing two people. Listen to how they survived now! Drink of the Week: Holiday Italian Soda

    40 min
See All (100)

4.4
out of 5
7 Ratings

About

Friends Caitlyn and Michelle drink and tell true stories of people who survived crime, natural disasters and everything else in between. On this bi-weekly podcast, we tell new stories each episode along with discussions and a little banter. We have a special drink each time, so grab a glass and join us! Let’s cheers to these amazing survivors as they should totally be dead right now.

Information

You Might Also Like