35 episodes

As of 2022 there are over 200,000 unsolved murders and missing person cases in the United States alone. In the most recent data analysis by the FBI, 50% of murders go unsolved. This unsolved homicide rate is at an all time high since the FBI began collecting the data in the 1960’s.
COLD RED – A true crime podcast series hosted by two of the most well respected criminal profilers in law enforcement history. Ride along with Ray and Fitz as they dive into various cold cases, innocence projects, and some of their classic, high profile, international cases.
Raymond Carr https://raymondjcarr.com
Ray joined the FBI following college, working the robbery-homicide division. He was soon promoted to the Bank Robbery division in Philadelphia, the city with the 2nd highest bank robbery and armored vehicle robbery rate in the nation. Ray later moved on to the Bureau’s Behavioral Science Unit building profiles on serial offenders. He was assigned to lead the Friday Night Bank Robber task force where Ray would build a profile for the most successful bank robber in American
History. Upon retirement, Ray wrote the book 30 Years On The Run about the capture and arrest of the robber and has since been featured on various series and documentaries discussing some of his high profile cases such as Homicide City and FBI: Criminal Pursuit on the Investigation Discovery.
“Cops don’t solve cases, the community does!”
“The victim is the most overlooked aspect of the crime by law enforcement.” -Ray Carr
James Fitzgerald www.jamesrfitzgerald.com
“Fitz” was a former Philadelphia Police Detective who later joined the FBI and was quickly promoted to the Behavioral Science Unit where he partnered up with Ray Carr building profiles on various criminals throughout the US. A forensic linguistics expert, Fitz is known for taking down the Unabomber and working several high profile cases like Jon Benet Ramsey and The DC Sniper. Upon retiring from the FBI, Fitz wrote a series of book volumes titled: Journey to the Center of the Mind and has been featured on numerous television shows including The Discovery Original Series – Manhunt: The Unabomber, where actor Sam Worthington played the role of Fitz.

Cold Red Podcast matthewfrobinson

    • True Crime
    • 4.3 • 22 Ratings

As of 2022 there are over 200,000 unsolved murders and missing person cases in the United States alone. In the most recent data analysis by the FBI, 50% of murders go unsolved. This unsolved homicide rate is at an all time high since the FBI began collecting the data in the 1960’s.
COLD RED – A true crime podcast series hosted by two of the most well respected criminal profilers in law enforcement history. Ride along with Ray and Fitz as they dive into various cold cases, innocence projects, and some of their classic, high profile, international cases.
Raymond Carr https://raymondjcarr.com
Ray joined the FBI following college, working the robbery-homicide division. He was soon promoted to the Bank Robbery division in Philadelphia, the city with the 2nd highest bank robbery and armored vehicle robbery rate in the nation. Ray later moved on to the Bureau’s Behavioral Science Unit building profiles on serial offenders. He was assigned to lead the Friday Night Bank Robber task force where Ray would build a profile for the most successful bank robber in American
History. Upon retirement, Ray wrote the book 30 Years On The Run about the capture and arrest of the robber and has since been featured on various series and documentaries discussing some of his high profile cases such as Homicide City and FBI: Criminal Pursuit on the Investigation Discovery.
“Cops don’t solve cases, the community does!”
“The victim is the most overlooked aspect of the crime by law enforcement.” -Ray Carr
James Fitzgerald www.jamesrfitzgerald.com
“Fitz” was a former Philadelphia Police Detective who later joined the FBI and was quickly promoted to the Behavioral Science Unit where he partnered up with Ray Carr building profiles on various criminals throughout the US. A forensic linguistics expert, Fitz is known for taking down the Unabomber and working several high profile cases like Jon Benet Ramsey and The DC Sniper. Upon retiring from the FBI, Fitz wrote a series of book volumes titled: Journey to the Center of the Mind and has been featured on numerous television shows including The Discovery Original Series – Manhunt: The Unabomber, where actor Sam Worthington played the role of Fitz.

    Biker Gangs & Violent Crimes - Cold Red sit with Greg Auld Part 1

    Biker Gangs & Violent Crimes - Cold Red sit with Greg Auld Part 1

    In this episode of Code Red, former FBI agent Greg Ault shares his experiences investigating violent crime and outlaw motorcycle gangs. Greg grew up in a tight-knit Irish Catholic neighborhood in Pennsylvania and joined the FBI after being encouraged by a friend’s father who was an FBI agent. He started his career in the Philadelphia office and later transferred to the New York office, where he worked on organized crime cases. Greg also worked on cases involving the IRA and had the opportunity to meet Joe Pistone, also known as Donnie Brasco. After nine years in New York, Greg transferred back to the Philadelphia office. In this conversation, Greg Fitz shares his experiences working in the FBI and as a private investigator, with a focus on outlaw motorcycle gangs and the Amish community. He discusses the challenges and dangers of infiltrating and investigating these groups, as well as the unique dynamics and subcultures within them. Fitz also highlights the importance of objective analysis in investigations and the need to make a difference in the world. Overall, this conversation provides insights into the world of law enforcement and private investigation, showcasing the diverse and impactful work done by professionals in these fields.

    • 24 min
    Dave MacNeil Remembers the Boston Marathon Bombings

    Dave MacNeil Remembers the Boston Marathon Bombings

    In this episode of Cold Red, host Ray Carr interviews Dave MacNeil, a retired police detective with over 37 years of experience. They discuss Dave’s background, his early years in law enforcement, changes in the police department, working background investigations, recruiting, police academy training, and his interest in forensics. In this part of the conversation, Dave MacNeil discusses his specialization in forensics and the formation of a crime scene unit. He highlights the importance of networking and gaining experience through collaboration with other departments. Dave explains the field of blood stain pattern analysis and its role in crime scene investigations. He also shares his experience during the Boston Marathon bombing and the subsequent shootout in Watertown. The chapter concludes with the capture of the suspects and the challenges faced in communication and jurisdictional issues. This conversation covers the events leading up to the capture of the Boston Marathon bomber, the unity and appreciation of law enforcement, the movie adaptation of the events, and Dave MacNeil’s retirement and new ventures.

    • 1 hr 15 min
    Nicole Hutchinson-Moore shares her background and the events that led to her incarceration

    Nicole Hutchinson-Moore shares her background and the events that led to her incarceration

    Nicole Hutchinson-Moore shares her background and the events that led to her incarceration. She grew up in a conservative, hardworking family but faced trauma and a fractured family dynamic. She struggled with her identity and began acting out, which eventually led to addiction and destructive behavior. One fateful night, she got behind the wheel after drinking and caused a fatal accident. Nicole reflects on the guilt and shame she carries for taking someone’s life and the pivotal moment when she realized she needed to change. She emphasizes the importance of making responsible choices and understanding the consequences of our actions. Nicole Hutchison-Moore shares her experience of being incarcerated and the shocking realities of the prison system. She discusses the lack of basic needs, the degrading treatment by staff, and the brokenness of the system. She emphasizes the importance of accountability and rehabilitation, rather than just punishment. Nicole also talks about her organization, Rusty Diamond Network, which supports individuals both inside and outside of prison, providing resources, guidance, and empowerment. She highlights the need for a community effort to create a safer and healthier society.

    • 1 hr 22 min
    Natalie Di Sabatino Tells Cold Red the Unfortunate Truth the Life of Victims Family

    Natalie Di Sabatino Tells Cold Red the Unfortunate Truth the Life of Victims Family

    Natalie Di Sabatino Tells Cold Red the Unfortunate Truth the Life of High Profile Victims Family

    • 50 min
    Tim Clemente shares his experiences in law Enforcement and Hollywood with Cold Red

    Tim Clemente shares his experiences in law Enforcement and Hollywood with Cold Red

    In this episode, Tim Clemente, a former FBI agent, shares his experiences working in law enforcement, including his time in the St. Louis Metro PD and the FBI. He discusses the challenges of working in a violent district and shares a memorable case from his time in St. Louis. Tim also talks about his undercover work in South America and his involvement in the National Capital Response Squad. He concludes by discussing his expertise in Somali terrorism. Tim discusses his experiences in Somalia, including the relationship between the Somali clans and the events of Black Hawk Down. He also talks about piracy in Somalia and his involvement in the Captain Phillips case. Tim shares his close relationship with the President of Somalia and his role in counterterrorism efforts. He then transitions to his work in Hollywood and his decision to stay in the US instead of deploying to Afghanistan. Tim discusses his involvement in XG Productions and Audible, focusing on true crime projects. He also mentions his support for veterans and indigenous communities.
    Takeaways
    Working in law enforcement requires dedication and a passion for protecting the community.
    Prosecutors play a crucial role in ensuring justice is served and keeping communities safe.
    Whitewater rafting trips can be thrilling and memorable experiences.
    The National Capital Response Squad is a specialized unit that responds to emergencies and terrorist attacks in the Washington, DC area. The Somali people were not the attackers in the Black Hawk Down incident, but rather the ones working with the American military. The majority of Somalis were pro-American, but radical forces drowned out their voices.
    Piracy in Somalia is driven by both greed and the absence of a central government to patrol the waters. Illegal fishing is also a major issue in Somali waters.
    Tim developed a close relationship with the President of Somalia and worked together on counterterrorism efforts. This relationship was beneficial for both the US and Somalia in the fight against Al Qaeda.
    Tim transitioned from the FBI to working in Hollywood, where he has been involved in writing, producing, and consulting on various projects.
    Tim is dedicated to supporting veterans and indigenous communities, particularly in addressing the issue of missing and murdered indigenous women.

    • 1 hr 24 min
    The GodFather of the Behavioral Science Unit - Gregg McCrary

    The GodFather of the Behavioral Science Unit - Gregg McCrary

    In this episode of Cold Red, retired supervisory special agent Greg McCrary discusses his experiences as a profiler in the FBI’s Behavioral Science Unit. He shares stories from his early career, including his first major case involving a serial rapist in Toronto. McCrary also reveals the breakthrough in the case of Paul Bernardo and Carla Homolka, who were responsible for a series of rapes and murders. He discusses the process of recognizing patterns and building a profile to catch serial offenders. The episode highlights the importance of investigative strategies and the role of experience in profiling. Greg McCrary discusses various cases and his work in profiling, including the pattern of behavior in serial killers, the creation of the Crime Classification Manual, the establishment of profiling units in Canada, the Jack Unterweger case, the Sam Shepard homicide case, and the Police Fellowship Program. He also mentions his book, The Unknown Darkness, which explores profiling and the role it plays in criminal investigations.

    • 1 hr 16 min

Customer Reviews

4.3 out of 5
22 Ratings

22 Ratings

jjsmith 34 ,

Facts

I love your show and I’ve given it 5 stars BUT I really dislike that you misstate facts. Rebecca Shaffer was shot not stabbed. It’s was Elizabeth Smart that was kidnapped in Utah. I don’t expect you to keep all this in your memory, but if I can so can you! Keep up the good show. I love hearing the details of a real FBI agent’s daily work!

Perry C. ,

Gave this podcast a second try and was disappointed

I had heard Jim Fitzgerald on numerous podcasts over several years and was impressed with his experience, his expertise in forensic linguistics, storytelling skills, down-to-earth delivery combined with depth. I was not familiar with Ray Carr but assumed if he was co-hosting Cold Red and had a highly respected career in the FBI, he would be engaging, interesting, and insightful. The podcast was promoted as “riveting”. I looked forward to it!

Some episodes were interesting but I found the co-hosts delivery to be anything but naturally conversational or engaging. I kept hoping for improvement once they were up and running for a while. Sometimes they even seemed ill prepared. There overwhelming rah rah for the FBI and police got old fast. I have respect for both, and both organizations screw up, make mistakes and sometimes behave egregiously. Additionally, sometimes Fitz’s ego went into overdrive and he drowned out Ray. Despite these negatives, I really wanted this podcast to live up to expectations, so I stuck with it.

Lack of preparedness with some guests (or disinterest? disrespect? lack of sleep?) made their comments, follow-ups, and questions almost painful to listen to. I finally gave up after Season 3, February 26, 2024 episode with Tom Simon, former FBI agent in forensic accounting. This interview could have been so interesting! Mr. Simon tried to take their inane one-word responses and multiple examples of poor listening in a more intelligent and curious direction. He threw them some bones in an effort to expand the conversation without making them look like dullards.

I had to hit stop. I’m done with Cold Red.

BreeLeigh ,

Ohhh it’s an Alt-Right show

Kind of terrifying to hear host & a supposed FBI agent peddling Trump’esque nonsense when I expected to hear a conversation about cold cases. Not all podcasts are equal.

Top Podcasts In True Crime

Blood is Thicker: The Hargan Family Killings
CBS News
Dateline NBC
NBC News
Crime Junkie
audiochuck
Beyond All Repair
WBUR
Morbid
Morbid Network | Wondery
Status: Untraced
Tenderfoot TV & Audacy

You Might Also Like

Mind Over Murder
William F. Thomas and Kristin M. Dilley
The Murder In My Family
AbJack Entertainment
Best Case Worst Case
X-G Productions
DNA: ID
AbJack Entertainment
Missing Persons
AbJack Entertainment
MURDERISH
Cloud10