I adore Jackie, MJ, and Holden. I’m heartbroken that Holden is leaving this podcast. My husband’s only podcast of choice is an NPR food thing, but he knows mine while shower. His eyes glaze over whenever I mention things I learn or hear from podcasts, but I have made a minor dent in my handsome man’s brain about Affleck’s ‘sad Dad’ energy, Jackie’s gorgeous voice, MJ’s hilarious Mormon TV obsession, and Holden’s unbridled enthusiasm. I’m going to miss Holden very, very deeply. I liked him getting put to business by Jackie when he veered off course. I love that Jackie wants her show to be friendly and kind. I love MJ living in NYC and making time to record something across time zones so my husband recognizes the voice even when he isn’t much of a podcast dude. Thank you, Page 7. 😙

I am so glad I finally downloaded this pod! Especially the talkin TV. I love it. I was introduced to both Jackie and Holden on LPOTL and loved them individually. Add MJ in the mix and it’s a treat! Keep it up page 7. You are my new go to soothing podcast.

I’ve listened to this show for years, back to when it was Marcus as the cohost. The show has just become mean spirited. They feel so hypocritical the way they talk about people

I love their weird & funny banter, trying to please the haters but stay true to how they communicate in their genuine friendship must be hard. From Roundtable to here…. I love it! Even the Holden cringey moments … like an annoying brother that means well. 😂❤️

I’ve been a fan for many years and it’s just not the same. As a matter of fact, the hubs and I have loved these people since the RTOG days. My husband and I used to love listening together. He refuses to listen now. They literally piss him off. I defended them and kept listening, because I’m loyal to a fault. He was right. I won’t go into the many reasons why, because it really doesn’t matter. They’re doing their thing, and I’m just not going to give them my very valuable time. When you forget where you came from, it shows and it’s disappointing.

I love their bits, I love their chemistry, and I love all 3 hosts!

I’m a big LPL fan. So I decided to try a couple of their network shows. I loved Page 7 more than I’d like to admit. Marcus, Jackie, and MJ were great. The vibe was silly, laid back, and just fun. When Holden first joined I didn’t mind at all, as a former roundtable listener, more Holden’s never a bad thing. However, I’ve noticed lately they’ve become so careful about basically every topic. They’re often so worried about possibly offending someone it’s made the show less entertaining. I really don’t enjoy the other fans I’ve had contact with. They’re just sanctimonious and annoying. Idk if the show will ever be nearly as good as it was, but I’ll keep listening. Every once and awhile it’s still fun, but lately those moments seems further and further apart.

Terrible podcast and their IT guy is just the worst.

This isn’t entertainment. The lady sounds way too annoying

Update: I’m officially done after ten years. Somehow both dull and mean-spirited now, except for the Tay content, which to be fair is 75% of the content. The hypocrisy is unbearable. Don’t hate Tay, but didn’t come here for Tay, and whichever stream you listen to, it’s all about Tay. I understand that she desperately needs more publicity… there just isn’t enough content devoted to her as a struggling, starving artist. And yes, I am, soon to be was, a $10 a month Patreon subscriber, where even on the Buffy watch-a-longs, it’s still Taylor all the time. At this point in the US, WE CAN GET TAY CONTENT JUST BY SNEEZING TOO HARD. If I were to direct any of Holden’s completely debasing comments during the Buffy watch-alongs toward Tay, he’d be the first to crucify me. So stick a fork in me. Done. ***** I have loved this show and have been a Patreon subscriber for almost a decade. I loved it with Marcus, I grew to love Holden, I’ve loved MJ’s journey and greater contribution to the show. But it seems like Holden has started to run roughshod over the pod lately—more of his voice than anyone else’s, more Taylor talk than is warranted given what I thought the podcast was meant to be—a fun, irreverent joyfest. I am on the brink of canceling my Patreon, even with the Buffy watch-alongs, because I really want to hear more from MJ and Jackie.